Companies Cave in to Online Porn Campaign, Cut Ties to Christian Web Business
By Martha Kleder
Retail merchants J.C. Penney, Nordstrom, and CVS Pharmacy have ended their association with the Christian on-line shopping mall KingdomBuy.com, following a smear campaign organized by online sex clubs.
The retailers were among these being targeted by members of Yahoo! sex clubs in retaliation for the recent victory of pro-family groups. The groups successfully challenged Yahoo! to remove child pornography and obscenity from its servers. Yahoo! also discontinued the distribution of adult sex merchandise.
I am shocked that reputable merchants such as J.C. Penney and Nordstrom would be persuaded by a small group of pornographers, said Gary Sutton, President of KingdomBuy.com.
It sounds like you have some conclusions that
from our perspective at least would be erroneous, Jeanine Connelly public relations director for JCPenney.com told C&F Report, when asked to respond to Suttons statement. Connelly added that the decision by JCPenney.com to disassociate itself with KingdomBuy.com was unrelated to any organized e-mail campaign, but instead was based on sound business grounds.
At the time of publication, there had been no response from J.C. Penney to a consumer e-mail complaining about the change and supporting KingdomBuy.com.
However, one of many postings on the 11,500-member Yahoo! sex club encouraged members to contact retailers associated with KingdomBuy.com, with the message: It has come to our attention that your company is associated with the American Family Associations on-line shopping Web site entitled KingdomBuy.com. This organization, while claiming to be pro-family, is actually in effect pro-censorship.
[message #3983].
The American Family Association (AFA) is one of about 9,000 churches and ministries supported by the online Christian mall.
Within a week of the first messages, four major retailers, including JCPenney.com, ended their relationship with KingdomBuy.com, most without explanation. They arent even calling us back, Sutton told C&F Report.
Corporate values are being turned on their head when it comes to family values, said David Miller, AFAs National Field Director, when asked why mainstream merchants would side with viewers of pornography over families.
The only merchant to provide KindomBuy.com with an explanation was Nordstrom. They told us they couldnt do business with us because we were a Christian organization, Sutton said.
ShaSha Richardson, public relations director for Nordstrom, confirmed that reason in an interview with the American Family Association Journal, saying Our customers have so many diverse faiths
that, to honor that diversity, as a business we need to apply [our policy] consistently across the board.
But Sutton adds that Nordstrom knew from the beginning of its 10-month relationship with KingdomBuy.com that it was dealing with a Christian business.
Miller told C&F Report that the situation smacks of religious bigotry and hypocrisy, Nordstroms participates with iGive.com, providing money to homosexual organizations, Buddhists and many others. He also wonders if merchants are aware the campaign is being led by the pornography industry.
Weve communicated with our other affiliated retailers and informed them of the e-mail campaign, says Sutton. Miller is encouraging pro-family Christians to support that effort by thanking the retailers still onboard with KingdomBuy.com, and expressing their concern to those businesses that have ended their relationship.
Such action may have led to Avon reinstating its relationship with KingdomBuy.com. Avon was one of the original four retailers that ended its relationship with the online mall just days after the start of the pornographers e-mail campaign.
KingdomBuy.com markets a host of secular businesses to Christians by returning a portion of a shoppers invoice total to the church or ministry of their choice. Participating merchants include Dell Computer, Hickory Farms, Wal-Mart, and Office Max.
KingdomBuy.com was originally formed to support Christian mission work. It has grown to include local churches, para-church ministries, and ministries that also do family advocacy work like the American Family Association and Jerry Falwell Ministries. All of the 9,000 or more ministries must agree with a Biblical statement of faith.
The shopper can choose any ministry they wish to support, or if they prefer, non-supporters can take that amount as a discount off of their bill, so I dont see how we discriminate against anybody, Sutton said.
While J.C. Penney representatives have returned calls to the press on this issue, at press time they still had not contacted KingdomBuy.com President Gary Sutton.
Contact information:
J.C. Penney Company, Inc.
Allen Questrom, Chairman
Vanessa Castagna, Executive Vice President
6501 Legacy Drive
Plano, TX 75024-3698
Customer Relations: 972-431-8200
Fax: 972-431-1362
You may also contact the office of J.C.Penney.com:
Jeanine Connelly, Public Relations Director for JCPenney.com
Telephone: 972-591-7271. You can also contact them on their contact page.
You can also thank Avon:
AVON
Kristin Cleary Graves
EMarketing Manager
3 Park Avenue
New York, NY 10016
Telephone: 917-326-8818
Fax: 917-326-8832
Email: Kristin.graves@avon.com
You can also support the ministry of your choice by visiting www.kingdombuy.com.
